Top Beginner Supplements I Would Never Take

These are the most common beginner bodybuilding supplements, and they could be hurting your health.
Some people won’t like this.
Here’s what’s wrong with the modern supplement industry, how I used to take these supplements, why I would never take them today, and what I take instead for each one.
What’s Wrong With the Supplement Industry
Synthetic supplements are mostly made from petroleum, among other processed things. Coal tar, acetylene and crude oil distillates. There’s a whole list.
Even the healthy supplements you take for your health are made with kerosene and acetone as solvents. Producers don’t need to list those in the ingredients, even though traces may remain.
Here’s how it happened. The modern supplement industry grew directly out of the petrochemical boom of the early 20th century. The same companies refining fuel started refining your vitamins, because they saw how much money they could make.
Isolated synthetic nutrients are missing the cofactors, the enzymes and the phytonutrients that make the whole natural substance work. You get a Frankenstein skeleton approximation without the life force that makes it function.
And what they’re approximating doesn’t actually exist in nature. They make something in a lab, call it vitamin C, and say, look, it’s in oranges too. What they’ve made is nothing compared to what’s actually in an orange.
The Beginner Stack I Fell For
I got into all of these because they’re recommended as the beginner bodybuilding stack on early fitness forums and generic bodybuilding sites. The starter pack:
- Creatine
- Fish oil
- Sunshine pills, sold as a sun replacement
- Synthetic magnesium
- Protein powder
- A multivitamin
I fell for it all.
And I’ll say it specifically and truthfully. I feel better and healthier, with cleaner gains and more muscle, since dropping every one of these, which I did many years ago.
Here’s each one. What it is, how it’s made, and what nature already provides that makes it unnecessary.
1. Creatine
This is the one nobody questions.
Creatine monohydrate or hydrochloride. The most studied, most recommended supplement in the fitness world. Every forum, every coach, every influencer. Just take creatine, bro. Five grams a day for your muscles and your brain. Take 20 grams. Take 100 grams. It’s just creatine, man.
Nobody asks what industrial creatine monohydrate is synthesised from.
It’s made by reacting sarcosine, a formaldehyde derivative, with cyanamide inside a chemical reactor. Cyanamide is a compound toxic enough to be used as a pesticide. The reaction uses various acids to crystallise the final product. The raw inputs trace back to coal tar and other petroleum derivatives.
You’re spooning petrochemical powder into your water and calling it gains because your body holds a little water, which you can do with salt. So why is it blasted all over social media as the one supplement to rule them all?
Here’s what your body already does. Your liver and kidneys synthesise creatine naturally. What your body makes is a different thing from that white powder, no matter how often they claim it’s exactly the same.
What I do instead
Red meat and wild-caught fish are the richest dietary sources, and they’re all you need, especially if you eat raw meat. A pound of quality steak gives you roughly 2 g of natural creatine your body can use, delivered whole with every cofactor intact and none of the chemical BS.
Eat raw meat. Your biology handles the rest.
I used creatine back in the day. I haven’t taken it in years, and I’m the biggest and strongest I’ve ever been. Riddle me that.
That’s the pattern with every supplement on this list. Nature already solved the problem. The industry repackaged it in a lab in an inferior, chemical, profitable form and sold it back to you.
2. Fish Oil
Rancid sludge in a capsule.
The heart-healthy omega-3. Let’s talk about what’s actually inside those capsules.
Commercial fish oils are mostly rendered from waste fish. Heads, tails, guts, skin and bones left over from industrial fish processing. Fish parts are fine. What they do next is the problem.
The sludge is heated, pressed and chemically extracted to pull out the omega-3 fatty acids along with everything else.
Omega-3s, EPA and DHA, are polyunsaturated fats. That means they’re extremely unstable and prone to oxidation when heated. The moment these oils are extracted, processed, or exposed to heat, light or even air during processing, they start to go rancid.
Study after study has found that a significant percentage of the fish oil products on the shelves are already oxidised beyond acceptable levels by the time you buy them.
You’re swallowing rancid industrial fish sludge and calling it healthy. Oxidised polyunsaturated fats don’t prevent inflammation. They cause it.
The oil was already oxidised in the capsule. Then it sits on a warehouse shelf for six months before it reaches you.
What I do instead
Eat fresh fatty fish two to three times a week. Sardines, mackerel, salmon, tuna, herring, swordfish. Whatever is local to you will be best and freshest.
The omega-3s are protected inside the cellular structure of the fish, delivered alongside the antioxidants and cofactors your body needs to use them. That’s the delivery system nature designed.
Skip the fish oil. Eat fresh fish. Very simple.
3. The Sunshine Pill
You cannot replace the sun with a pill. Plenty of people have been told you can.
The hormones your body produces in response to sunlight go far beyond any one compound, and they’re a different thing from what you buy in a capsule, even though the capsule is marketed as a sun replacement.
The synthetic sunshine pill is made by irradiating either fungal matter or lanolin extracted from sheep’s wool grease. The irradiated material is then processed with industrial solvents. Methanol, chloroform, hexane. The same industrial solvents used to extract seed oils. There are neurotoxic compounds involved in making this supplement.
The final product is mixed with binders, fillers and stabilisers, then pressed into a pill or suspended in a carrier oil.
The names on the bottle are labels. What’s inside isn’t what exists in your body. It’s a mix of isolated, processed, extracted chemicals. It’s dead, and it’s no replacement for the sun.
What happens naturally is far more elegant. When sunlight touches your skin, cholesterol molecules are transformed into the hormones your body needs, with the help of bacteria living on your skin. No solvents, no irradiation, no lab. That’s a living process. A pill is a dead imitation, and calling it an imitation is generous. It’s another fake thing people have been calling by the same name.
What about winter?
But Sol Brah, what do I do in winter without my sunshine pills?
Your body still produces its sunlight hormones when you go outside. Even on a cloudy day, even on a cold day, if light reaches your skin, production is happening to some degree. With less UV and less sun in winter you get less, but it’s still happening.
The problem is that people only go outside when it’s warm and sunny. When they do go out in the cold or the dark, they wear five layers and a beanie so none of their skin touches the elements. They never build cold tolerance, which matters a lot. That’s most of the reason their bodies aren’t making those hormones.
You still need to be outside, exposing your body to the elements. Is there daylight? Yes. Is it different from night? Yes. So there’s sunlight coming through that you can absorb.
Cold exposure matters too, because your mitochondria produce their own light and make those same hormones from it. That’s a deeper topic for another time.
What I do instead
- Get outside every day, even in winter. Take cold, brisk walks and get your clothing off at least briefly, for 20 to 30 minutes.
- Eat raw animal foods. The nutrients your body pairs with sunlight are concentrated in raw animal foods, particularly raw meat. A lot of the nutrient factors are lost when you cook it.
- Cod liver, if you can find a really good, fresh, non-oxidised source.
- Raw butter and raw dairy. A fantastic source of the nutrients you need to stay happy and healthy in winter.
- Sit by fires.
Do all that and you’ll be fine through winter.
You can also look into red light therapy or UV lamps. They’re technically unnatural, and I’d still use them before I’d use sunshine pills.
The sun is free. It’s been the primary source for every civilisation that ever existed, giving your body far more than one isolated compound. Don’t be scared of the sun. It’s much healthier than the chemical products they’re selling.
4. Synthetic Magnesium
Magnesium is probably the one people hear about most. You take it, you sleep better, your muscles relax, you feel calmer. So it must be good, right?
It depends entirely on the form and how it was made. You can’t grab any magnesium off the shelf and expect the best effect on your body. Here are the two most common forms.
Magnesium citrate
The most commonly recommended form. It’s made by reacting magnesium carbonate rock with citric acid.
Citric acid sounds nice. Maybe it comes from a lemon. It’s actually produced by industrial fermentation using GMO black mould fungus fed on corn syrup.
The result is a lab-made chelate. The absorption is terrible and it’s harsh on the gut. People taking it are essentially taking a chemical laxative, and the magnesium never truly saturates the body to build genuine cellular health.
Magnesium glycinate
Marketed as the gentle premium option. Pretty much the same problem.
The glycine is synthesised from ammonia and chloroacetic acid, both industrial chemicals. That synthetic glycine is heated with crushed magnesium rock, and industrial alcohol solvents precipitate the final crystals.
It’s chemically manufactured slop in better packaging.
The taste test
Open the capsule, pour out the powder and taste it. Does it taste good? Does it taste natural, like something your body should absorb?
No. It tastes like fish disgustingness. No offence to fish. People don’t notice when they swallow it as a capsule. Your body inherently rejects things this processed and this full of chemicals.
What I use instead
I use natural liquid magnesium. The one I take is AURUM.
Natural liquid magnesium is distilled from ancient lake water deposits. It’s distilled by nature in the sun, never assembled in a chemical reactor. It’s in ionic form, which allows instant cellular uptake with no digestion needed to break it down. Dissolve it in water and it’s in highly absorbable magnesium ions, in a very concentrated form.
Your body recognises it immediately. That’s the difference between a supplement from nature and one from a chemical reactor.
Beyond supplements, there are whole food sources. Raw milk and raw cacao are magnesium-rich foods that sustained human health for thousands of years without a single capsule. And ocean bathing. Ocean water is very rich in natural magnesium.
5. Protein Powder
Dead dairy waste.
The gym staple. The post-workout shake. Got to get those gains in right after training. That was the original marketing ploy for a lot of the early brands, and it’s what every beginner is told he needs.
Commercial protein powders mostly use waste whey. The dairy industry had all this offshoot from industrial cheese manufacturing and asked what to do with it. Repackage it as protein, and you can sell it.
Whey itself is actually very nutritious. The problem is the manufacturing. High-heat processing to dry it. Sometimes irradiation to kill the scary bacteria. That denatures the proteins and destroys the beneficial enzymes, the immunoglobulins and the lactoferrin that made whey valuable in the first place. That’s why milk is healthy and nutritious.
What’s left is a dead protein isolate. The ghost of a nutrient.
Then come the artificial flavourings. Bubble gum flavour protein. Sweeteners like sucralose, which everyone knows hurt the gut. Thickeners like xanthan gum. Various chemical additives. All to make a cookie dough milkshake that appeals to low IQ consumers, like I used to be.
You drink chemically flavoured, processed dairy waste and wonder why your gut is wrecked. I’ve seen so many people swap away from protein shakes and their gut performs better. They stop farting all the time, and they absorb the nutrients from the rest of their meals way better.
What I do instead
- Drink raw milk. A litre of raw milk gives you roughly 32 grams of complete protein with all the bioactive compounds still alive and functional. Your body knows what to do with it.
- Eat Greek yogurt, which is concentrated in protein.
- Eat eggs.
That’s all you need to build a powerful body. You don’t need concentrated protein powder slop that relies on marketing.
6. Multivitamins
The worst offender. It combines everything wrong with all of the above into one compressed tablet.
The ingredient list is 50 things long. People look at it and think, look at all these nutrients. I’m covered with this little pill, so I can eat fast food and it’s all good.
A multivitamin is a trash bag of dozens of synthetic chemicals.
- Vitamin B12 as cyanocobalamin. The cyano prefix means it contains a cyanide molecule, which is obviously bad for you.
- Folic acid, vitamin E, vitamin K, and the rest of the laundry list of alleged nutrients.
- Iron as ferrous sulfate. Essentially rust.
All crammed together in doses that barely make a difference, competing with each other, if they’re absorbed at all. Are we actually absorbing these things? Are the amounts even relevant? No, and no.
That’s never been how nutrition works.
Even the whole food multivitamins, marketed as the natural alternative, are mostly synthetic vitamins sprayed onto yeast or a food base and relabelled.
What I do instead
A varied whole food diet:
- Organ meats
- Raw dairy
- Eggs
- Fresh food and fresh fruit
- Fermented foods
That covers all your bases. Add swimming outside in natural waters, getting sunlight, being outdoors all the time, and maybe a few concentrated natural supplements found in nature. You’ll be happy and healthy. That’s how it works.
Nature Already Solved It
Your gut works best extracting nutrients from a complex whole food matrix. That’s what biology intended. Nutrients bound in real food, with the enzymes and cofactors that unlock them, in ratios your body has developed with over thousands of years. Those foods existed long before the chronic illness and disease that plagues our society today.
People are eating less and less real food, and we’re getting sicker and sicker.
Coming back to what nature designed will always beat the labelled, packaged chemicals we’re told we need.
The supplement industry took something nature perfected, reverse engineered a dead copy of it, and spent billions telling you the copy is essential. Your essential vitamins, all in one pill. It isn’t essential.
Eat real food. Get sunlight. Drink clean water. Move your body. These are the fundamentals of life.
The things that work best have been here the entire time. Nature gives them to us. God gives them to us. They just can’t be patented and sold back to you at a markup.
My life and my health are far better since I left all of these behind.
The Swaps
- Creatine to raw red meat and wild-caught fish.
- Fish oil to fresh fatty fish two to three times a week.
- Sunshine pills to daily time outside, cold exposure, raw animal foods, raw butter and raw dairy.
- Synthetic magnesium to natural liquid magnesium (AURUM), raw milk, raw cacao and ocean swims.
- Protein powder to raw milk, Greek yogurt and eggs.
- Multivitamins to organ meats, raw dairy, eggs, fresh fruit and fermented foods.
Want the full way I eat? It’s all in The Warlord Diet.
Stay Golden, Sol
Get the guide. Read my emails.
Sign up and the Holistic Health Baseline lands in your inbox. Then you get my emails, sent direct from me.
- Exclusive content I don't post anywhere else
- Words of wisdom
- Holistic health tips


